The pick: Edge Abdul Carter, Penn State

Analysis: While Kiper doesn’t rule out the possibility of taking a quarterback, he considers the move the Browns made in trading for Pickett and the potential of a veteran quarterback to go another direction with the No. 2 pick. Kiper writes about the pairing of DE Myles Garrett and Carter together as top-tier edge rushers in defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz’s attack-style defense.

The pick: Edge Abdul Carter, Penn State

Analysis: Jeremiah writes the Browns could consider taking Carter at No. 2 and then look to take a quarterback in the second round instead of the other way around – an option he believes is the better choice for the Browns.

The pick: QB Cam Ward, Miami

Analysis: Baumgardner writes that he believes Ward is the best QB prospect in the 2025 NFL Draft, and If the Browns are sold on drafting a quarterback with the No. 2 pick, he would be the choice.

The pick: QB Shedeur Sanders, Colorado

Analysis: While Kosko mocks a trade for the Giants to jump to No. 1 to take Ward, he has the Browns staying at No. 2 and taking Sanders. Kosko writes the Browns need a quarterback to lead them back to contention and believes Sanders’ experiences can help him do so.

The pick: Edge Abdul Carter, Penn State

Analysis: Renner writes that if Ward is available at No. 2, he believes the Browns would take Ward. But if he’s not, the combination of Carter alongside former Defensive Player of the Year in Garrett over the next five seasons would be tough to pass on.

The pick: CB/WR Travis Hunter, Colorado

Analysis: Fowler views Hunter as an immediate plug-and-play starter for the Browns and writes that Hunner has All-Pro ceiling on both sides of the ball.