Toddzilla’s Bar Pizza Recipe (2024)

Bar Pizza

Toddzilla’s Bar Pizza Recipe (1) barpizzajm 9 Comments

4.6 / 6 Reviews

Jump To Recipe Print Recipe
Toddzilla’s Bar Pizza Recipe (2) View Gallery 5 photos

This recipe comes from Todd Mead, aka ToddZilla, A Raynham native now living in Colorado. Todd is working on converting a large RV into a bar pizza truck to bring delicious South Shore Bar Pizza out west. You can follow his progress here at ToddZilla’s South Shore Pizza Project.

For a complete list of everything you need to make south shore bar pizza at home, visit my buyers guide here.

Todd has also put the time into making a nice instructional video that you can watch right here. Happy pizza making!

Toddzilla’s Bar Pizza Recipe (12)

Print Recipe

4.6 from 6 votes

Toddzilla’s Bar Pizza Recipe

Author: barpizzajm Cooking Method: Baking Cuisine: American, BarPizza Courses: Bar Pizza

Difficulty: Beginner Prep Time 24 hour Cook Time 12 min Total Time 24 hrs 12 mins Servings: 4

Description

Todzilla's South Shore Bar Pizza Recipe

What you'll need

Dough

Sauce

Cheese

Instructions

Dough

  1. Put yeast, water, sugar, corn oil and melted butter in a bowl. Whisk briefly and allow to sit for 5 minutes.

  2. Add flour and salt. Mix with dough hook until everything is integrated and has formed a ball (about a minute and half med-low speed)

  3. Coat with oil and place in gallon ziplock or dough bin in fridge for at least 24 hours

  4. Pull dough out at least 1 hour before proofing in oven, or 3 hours before if proofing at room temperature.

  5. Divide the dough into four 6.5oz. portions, flatten them a bit, put them in pans oiled with 2 tsp. of corn oil
  6. Let them rise in the pans for 1/2 hour in the oven on "proof" or until nearly double in size at room temperature
  7. Pan them out all the way and proof them for another 1/2 hour in the oven or until they have visibly risen again at room temperature.

  8. Flatten and deflate the dough with your hands and make rows of tiny holes with your fingernails (about every inch so it looks like a golfball). You're ready for assembly!

Sauce

  1. Put all ingredients in blender and blend just until broken down and integrated (about 10-20 seconds)

  2. Use about 1/3c of sauce per 10" pizza
  3. This will make about 10 pizzas depending on how much sauce you like

Cheese

  1. Shred 1 lb. Sharp Cheddar and 1/2 lb. Mozzarella and mix to combine. (2:1)

  2. Use roughly one very large handful of cheese blend per pizza
  3. Add desired toppings

Baking

  1. Preheat oven to 500 convection with pizza stones laid on racks (Todd uses four 12" granite tiles) for roughly 1 hour

  2. Place pans on tiles and bake for 12 minutes (longer for non convection ovens)

  3. Remove pizza from pan with a peel and check bottom for golden brown color. Remove pizza from pan and place directly on stones for 2 minutes if needed. Cheese and light toppings are usually done, heavier/wetter toppings usually require more time

Keywords: Todzilla, Barpizza, Bar Pizza, Homemade pizza,

File under barpizzaTodzilla

Recipe Card powered by Toddzilla’s Bar Pizza Recipe (14)

  1. Nice job and much appreciated.

    1. The town spa family,(daughter) tried the Spa’s recipe in the Bahama’s. Flopped. One reason is the water. Even in the same country, water changes the taste of everything. Ask Coors beer, who opened a brewery in Virginia, only to see sales plummet, because the taste changed. Good luck.

      1. It could also be that different markets appreciate different kinds of pizza.

        Just take anywhere in Florida for example. The pizza is 99% sh*t. I’m sure countless North Easterners have gone down their wide eyed thinking they’d make a $1,000,000,000 selling NY Pies or something akin to Regina/Santarpios only to lose their pants.

        It was probably more that Bahamians didn’t like Bar Pie.

  2. Thanks! Would be improved recipes with baking percentages, they true pizza makers will appreciate. Alas, I’ll do some math.

  3. Have you tried this recipe with bread flour? I’ve mastered the other south shore bar pizza recipe and decided I prefer it with bread flour instead of AP. Just curious if it will play in this recipe too, I don’t see why not? I’ll try it as written first though, I’m digging the bulk ferment and second rise in the pan idea.

  4. What size pans do you use 10″ or 12″ ?

    1. It said 10″ in the recipe.

  5. I been using this recipe for a month or so. I can’t find a single thing to change. It’s better than many top SSBP restaurants. The only change I have made is that I’m cooking at 550, no stones or anything else in the oven. The corn oil does make a difference. Also, I was able to grab some cup and char pepperoni that a friend ordered online, love it, gets me that much closer to authentic. Would love to share the pic. Thanks again for sharing this recipe!

  6. Does this dough freeze well? My husband is a Brockton native and his late father actually worked at Tip Top. I grew up on Neapolitan pizza, I’d love to freeze several crust to be able to make when he wants it as I do with the Neapolitan crust.

Leave a Reply

Toddzilla’s Bar Pizza Recipe (2024)

FAQs

What is the best ratio for pizza dough? ›

The ratio of cups of flour to cups of water in a pizza dough recipe is 9:4. A pizza restaurant makes a large quantity of dough, using 36 cups of flour.

What does adding more water to pizza dough do? ›

In addition to making your crust lighter, increasing the hydration produces a higher yield (more dough).

How many inches is a bar pizza? ›

What the bar pie is is single-serving delight: an 8-to-10-inch personal pizza baked on a wafer-thin crust and topped with tomato sauce, shredded low-moisture mozzarella, and maybe pepperoni or mushrooms, if you're feeling fancy.

What is 70 hydration dough? ›

The dough at 70 percent hydration is easy to work with—not too stiff and not too floppy. Meanwhile, the long overnight rest develops flavor, so it's more than just a teaching tool; it's a good loaf of bread.

Is more or less yeast better for pizza dough? ›

The key to really good pizza dough is to use as little yeast as possible (about 1% - 1.5% of the weight of the flour) and to let the dough ferment in the fridge for at least 24 hours, preferably 48, and even as much as 72.

Is 00 or bread flour better for pizza dough? ›

American bread flour is commonly used for making NY-style or Detroit-style pan pizzas. The high gluten content in bread flour allows for a longer fermentation. This helps the dough develop a more complex flavor profile. The fineness of 00 flour is ideal for pizzeria-type light and airy Neapolitan pizza.

How long should you leave pizza dough to rise? ›

If you're planning to make pizza today, then give the dough a rise. Clean out the mixing bowl, coat it with a little oil, and transfer the dough back inside. Cover the bowl with plastic wrap or a kitchen towel and let the dough rise until doubled in size, 1 to 1 1/2 hours. Option 3 — Store the dough in the fridge.

Is milk better than water for pizza dough? ›

Did you know the protein and sugars in milk actually help strengthen pizza dough while baking and create a beautiful, golden-brown crust? Try it for yourself!

What does olive oil do to pizza dough? ›

The goal of adding oil to pizza dough is to improve the texture of the dough and flavor the finished crust. The oil will specifically: Making the dough softer will improve its capacity to stretch when rolled out. If you don't use any oil, the dough will pull apart and produce holes.

What is the difference between bar pizza and regular pizza? ›

Not all pizzas served in a bar are “bar pizza,” and bar pizza can be found outside bars (as at Austin's Via 313 Pizzeria). So what is it? A very thin pie that's pan-cooked until uniformly crisp and generously topped with no-frills combos that recall a pregourmet pizza era.

What is the difference between tavern style pizza and bar pizza? ›

I would say the only significant difference between the Metro NYC bar pies and the Midwest tavern pies is the way they are cut. Tavern-style pizzas are cut in a grid pattern. One might argue another noticeable difference is that the Chicago bar pies are thinner and crispier. More of a cracker-style crust.

What is bar pizza style? ›

Real bar pizza has a thicker, buttery crust and is made in a pan with high sides with lots of oil, so the dough essentially fries in the pan. It's also traditionally served with "burnt edges" or "laced edges", where you push the sauce and cheese to the sides so it drips down and caramelizes against the side of the pan.

What happens if not enough water in pizza dough? ›

This is relevant to pizza because varying the level of dough hydration directly affects the qualities of a finished crust. Too little hydration and the crust will be dense and dry, while too much water will result in a dough that is sticky, too fluid to shape and difficult to slide into the oven.

Is Wetter pizza dough better? ›

A dough with a lower hydration might be stiffer and less sticky, making it easier to handle but potentially producing a denser crust. On the other hand, a wetter dough (higher hydration) can be trickier to work with but may result in a crust that's airy and light.

How hot must the oven be before cooking the pizza? ›

Heat the oven.

The best oven temperature for pizza is between 450 and 500 degrees F (250 to 260 degrees C). Pizza ovens cook at temperatures between 800 and 900 degrees F. You can't get that hot in your home oven, but the higher you can go, the better. Place a pizza stone on a lower oven rack.

What is the oil to flour ratio for pizza dough? ›

When it comes to weighing out your components for pizza dough, the oil ratio should be between 2 and 3 percent of your overall flour, but not more than 5 percent. Always start with a small percentage and test your dough; remember that adding is always easier than subtracting.

Can you mix pizza dough too much? ›

Overmixing your dough leads to a dough ball that will not want to stretch and will keep snapping back to a smaller size. Overmixing is not the only thing that leads to snapping back. Over balling your dough will also contribute.

What is the secret to making pizza dough? ›

There are many tricks to achieving a tasty, homemade pizza dough that rises into a beautiful pizza crust, such as making sure your ingredients are at right temperature, using half bread flour for a stronger dough and half all-purpose flour for a nice rise, substituting honey for sugar to help caramelize the crust and ...

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Last Updated:

Views: 5753

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Birthday: 1992-02-16

Address: Suite 851 78549 Lubowitz Well, Wardside, TX 98080-8615

Phone: +67618977178100

Job: Manufacturing Director

Hobby: Running, Mountaineering, Inline skating, Writing, Baton twirling, Computer programming, Stone skipping

Introduction: My name is Wyatt Volkman LLD, I am a handsome, rich, comfortable, lively, zealous, graceful, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.